I swear to god I wasn’t making it up.

I swear, I thought I read a panel where Isaac and Spender were talking about, or about to, bring up a girl who was their mystery #4th person of the club before she *vanished* to parts unknown.

I swear I thought I read that that was in conversation

But then I couldn’t find it

The closest I got was

So Isaac referencing this to their mystery other club person made me think it was another girl (because they have two boys, so they need two girls to balance out) and then with more and more hints it just merged/further added into this missing 4th club member.

I mean, I still think this is valid, but I thought for sure there was a lot more evidence to my theory than just that^