Ok, I am going to tweak my previous statement.

Rose and Dave are giving the trolls effective ammo, but it only works if they are using it.

If someone tries to ‘poetry burn’ Dave, Dave wouldn’t give a shit. But if it was Rose, then it would be somewhat effective because Dave knows/trust Rose. But it is only ‘somewhat’ effective because that is how Rose tease/is friendly with Dave.

Anyone else will end up as an absolute mess